Loading...
31A-085 320 Elms Street Kathleen Maieuski- historic district permit applicationII. Purpose III. Project Description Describe nature of project: LJ II1 JUL 1 8 2007 ELM STREET HISTORIC MyRICT- 'COMMISSION Permit Application I. General Information K OEe.er., I I cu ei s Applicant Address a A u -d(A-Io G^ �c ool Telephone 5V-1- 1- 5 Fax Property Owner (if different from above) Address Telephone Building Address/ Location on Assessor's Zoning Map IA Parcel D� Deed /Property recorded in Hampshire County Registry of Deeds: Book: (0 Page: 3.5 Applicant should first file a Zoning Form with the Building Commissioner's Office to see if this Application is required. Except for exempted activities described in Section 26 -5 of the City Ordinance Chapter 26, no building or structure within the Elm Street Historic District shall be constructed, demolished or altered in any way that affects exterior architectural features without the appropriate permit from the Elm Street Historic District Commission. Applicants proposing non exempted activities must supply the required submission materials and proceed to a Public Hearing to obtain.a Certificate of Appropriateness or a Certificate of Hardship. New Construction Demolition Removal Addition V) Alteration Frorck door r e-- Oacem er-:\ File MP- 2008 -0004 APPLICANT /CONTACT PERSON MAIEWSKI PROPERTIES LLC ADDRESS/PHONE 218 AUDUBON RD 584 -5555 (1) PROPERTY LOCATION 320 ELM ST MAP 31A PARCEL 085 001 ZONE URB HD ("ZONING FILLED OUT Fee Paid Building Permit Filled out Fee Paid THIS SECTION FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY: PERMIT APPLICATION CHECKLIST Typeof Construction: ZPA REPLACE FRONT DOOR New Construction Non Structural interior renovations Addition to Existing Accessory Structure Building Plans Included: Owner/ Statement or License 3 sets of Plans Plot Plan ENCLOSED REQUIRED DATE THE FOLLOWING ACTIO HAS BEEN TAKEN ON THIS APPLICATION BASED ON INFORMATION PRES TED: Approved Additional permits required (see below) PLANNING BOARD PERMIT REQUIRED UNDER Intermediate Project Major Project: Site Plan AND /OR Special Permit with Site Plan Site Plan AND /OR Special Permit with Site Plan ZONING BOARD PERMIT REQUIRED UNDER: Finding Special Permit Variance* Received Recorded at Registry of Deeds Proof Enclosed Other Permits Required: Curb Cut from DPW Water Availability Sewer Availability Septic Approval Board of Health Well Water Potability Board of Health Permit from Conservation Commission Permit from CB Architecture Committee Permit from Elm S et Commission Signature of Building Official Date Note: Issuance of a Zoning permit does not relieve a applicant's burden to comply with all zoning requirements and obtain all required permits from Board of Health, Conservation Commission, Department of public works and other applicable permit granting authorities. k Variances are granted only to those applicants who meet the strict standards of MGL 40A. Contact the Office of Planning Development for more information. Please type or print all information and return this form to the Building Inspector's Office with the $15 fling fee (check or money order) payable to the City of Northampton 1. Name of Applicant: C��ee- 1 `'Ltz S1 Address: oo-i,_ c 2. Owner of Property:�`�. Address: Telephone: S Sss Telephone: 3. Status of Applicant: Owner v Contract Purchaser Lessee Other (explain) 4. Job Location: Existing Use of Structure /Property: 6. Description of Proposed Use /Work /Project /Occupation: (Use additional sheets if necessary): Needs to be obtained 7. Attached Plans: Sketch Plan Site Plan Engineered /Surveyed Plans 8. Has a Special Permit /Variance /Finding ever been issued for /on the site? NO DON'T KNOW YES IF YES, date issued: IF YES: Was the permit recorded at the Registry of Deeds? NO DON'T KNOW YES IF YES: enter Book Page and /or Document 9.Does the site contain a brook, body of water or wetlands? NO 1f DONT KNOW YES IF YES, has a permit been or need to be obtained from the Conservation Commission? Obtained date issued: (Form Continues On Other Side) W:\ Documents \FORMS \original \Building Inspector\Zoning Permit Application passive.doc 8/4/2004 Peg Keller From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Peg Keller Housing and Community Development Planner Office of Planning and Development City of Northampton 210 Main Street Northampton MA 01060 telephone: 413 587 -1288 fax: 413 587 -1264 pkeller@northamptonma.gov Anthony Patillo Wednesday, October 24, 2007 11:40 AM Peg Keller; Anthony Patillo 'Chris Kennedy (E- mail)'; 'Edy Ambroz (E- mail)'; 'Louise Jeffway (E- mail)'; 'Marissa Labozetta (E- mail)'; Martha Lyon (E- mail); 'Norman Winston (E- mail)'; Pauline Fogel (E -mail) RE: 320 Elm /Borawski If the board denies and she does not change door, it seems there is no other choice but fines...what is Kathy due process as far as appealing boards decision? Superior Court? Original Message From: Peg Keller Sent: Wednesday, October 24, 2007 11:32 AM To: Tony Patillo (E -mail) Cc: Chris Kennedy (E- mail); Edy Ambroz (E- mail); Louise Jeffway (E- mail); Marissa Labozetta (E- mail); Martha Lyon (E- mail); Norman Winston (E- mail); Pauline Fogel (E -mail) Subject: 320 Elm /Borawski Hi/ need your help/ Kathy Maiewski reacted very maturely to the decision of the Elm Street Historic District commission/ which was to deny her replacement of a wooden door with a metal door, by painting the metal door orange. Wayne says enforcement with fines is a pain.. but the Commission is not interested in letting her get away with this.. your thoughts? Peg From: Anthony Patillo Sent: Wednesday, October 24, 2007 1:34 PM To: Peg Keller Subject: RE: 320 Elm /Borawski Peg Keller will she explore of due process? is she aware of her right of appeal? Original Message From: Peg Keller Sent: Wednesday, October 24, 2007 11:47 AM To: Anthony Patillo Subject: RE: 320 Elm /Borawski first with Pioneer Vally Planning Commission, within 20 days, then Superior Court Peg Keller Housing and Community Development Planner Office of Planning and Development City of Northampton 210 Main Street Northampton MA 01060 telephone: 413- 587 -1288 fax: 413 587 -1264 pkeller @northamptonma.gov Original Message From: Anthony Patillo Sent: Wednesday, October 24, 2007 11:40 AM To: Peg Keller; Anthony Patillo Cc: 'Chris Kennedy (E- mail)'; 'Edy Ambroz (E- mail)'; 'Louise Jeffway (E- mail)'; Marissa Labozetta (E- mail)'; Martha Lyon (E- mail); 'Norman Winston (E- mail)'; Pauline Fogel (E -mail) Subject: RE: 320 Elm /Borawski If the board denies and she does not change door, it seems there is no other choice but fines...what is Kathy due process as far as appealing boards decision? Superior Court? Original Message From: Peg Keller Sent: Wednesday, October 24, 2007 11:32 AM To: Tony Patillo (E -mail) Cc: Chris Kennedy (E- mail); Edy Ambroz (E- mail); Louise Jeffway (E- mail); Marissa Labozetta (E- mail); Martha Lyon (E- mail); Norman Winston (E- mail); Pauline Fogel (E -mail) Subject: 320 Elm /Borawski Hi/ need your help/ Kathy Maiewski reacted very maturely to the decision of the Elm Street Historic District commission/ which was to deny her replacement of a wooden door with a metal door, by painting the metal door orange. Wayne says enforcement with fines is a pain.. but the Commission is not interested in letting her get away with this.. your thoughts? Peg Peg Keller Housing and Community Development Planner Office of Planning and Development 24C- 044 -001 O'SIIEA D EL J BEATRICE H 333 EL T NORF'IAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 002 -001 KUENY TU 330 EL .T NORT AMPTON, MA 01060 KER MELISSA 31A-006-001 JOHNSON H KEITH NANCY N 9 MASSASOIT ST NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A-009-001 DARDANO KRISTIN L 281' ELM ST NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 078 -001 MESSER PERRY JUDITH I 276 ELM ST NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 081 -0.1 OH PAUL 39 MU IROE ST NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 084 -001 JEFFWAY).OUISE E WILLIAM F 22S ,EL 'ST NORyPIAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 087 -001 BARBER ROBERT E 16 VERNON ST NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 121 -001 RECHTSC 1AFFEN ROBERT E 5 JEWE ST NORTiPIAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 124 -001 PINNEG COLLEEN B f4 JEW T ST NO AMPTON, MA 01060 3CK C;1 J� 24C- 080 -001 FORD ••MICHZ D MARY L 6 MASSA ST NORT7AMPTON, MA 01060 3IA- 003 -001 NOLAN DINIS R ARLENE T 319 ELM NO0AMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 007 -001 BERTR IARRY G 293 EI, ST NOWt HAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 010 -001 FOLEY REBECCA B KEVIN K 275 ELM ST NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 079 -001 FITZGERALD REALTY CORPORATION P 0 BOX 60445 FLORENCE, MA 01062 31A- 082 -001/ ANDREW,ROBERT P P O BO 686 NOR)P AMPTON, MA 01061 31A- 085 -001 MAIEWSI PROPERTIES LLC 218 AMDUB ON RD LEEDS, MA 01053 31A-119-00)p RODRIGUES ANTHONY P 15 JEWTT ST NO7 AMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 122 -001 GINTIS HO.BERT MARCI S 15 FORBES AVE NOReHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 125 -001 KUDLER L R NANCY A FLAM 10 JEWyv T ST NO AMPTON, MA 01060 24C- 081 -001 JACOBSON-KENT A MARTHA LYON 313 ELM ST NORTIrI'(MPTON, MA 01060 31A- 004 -001 SATORSI LENA DALE CYRIL 309 EJ�, ST NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 008 -001 LOMB ARDELLI JOSEPH B 289 ELM ST NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 077 -001 y SCAGEL EDIN MEGAN MCCARTyf 22 JEWBTT ST NO ,tfl'HAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 080 -001 KUTER GEOFFREY A 292 ELW T NOR *1i1AMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 083 -00 WAKIN EANOR 302 EL ST NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 086 -00x"` BORA THOMAS E 12 VERNON ST NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 120 -00}/ SCAGEL N N 9 JETT ST NO THAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 123 -001 BIDWELL. ENNIS P 19 FORBEES AVE NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 126 -001 LEBEAU HER H VIRGINIA M 6 JEWET ST NOR, AMPTON, MA 01060 31A -127 -001 n BOND HOWALD E 25 FORBES,AVE NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A -147 -001 FOGEL BRUCE M PAULINE 'd6IDW A 1`6P1~ORBES AVE NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A-150-001 ALBERTS LEONARD I BERNICE W 3 HIGH MEADOW RD FLORENCE, MA 01062 999 999 -001/ Iladley T, wn Hall Hadley MA 01035 999 •999 -004 4 l lia sburg Town Hall VJillif�a'''msburg 4 01096 31A- 145 -001 HARTMANN HOLLY E 24 FORBES AVE NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 148 -001 OLSON MARY CHRISTINE 12 FORBES AVE NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A-328-001 ANTIL ROB RT E CLAUDIA R VIELE 701 W2STHAMPTON RD N9RTHAMPTON, MA 01062 999 999 -00y Hatfield, .own Hall Hatfield MA 01038 31A -082 300 Elm Street September 7, 2007 31A-146-001 SADOWSKI EDWARD W 20 FORBES AVE NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 31A- 149 -001 DAVID JUSTIN JUDITH WOLF 15 MAYNARD RD NORTHAMPTON, MA 01060 999 999- 000 Easthammon Town Hall Easthampton MA, 01027 999 999 -003 Westhampn''I'own Hall Westhampton MA,`01027 1� TO: Kathy Maiewski, Property Owner 320 Elm Street FROM: Peg Keller, Housing and Community Development Planner RE: Elm Street Historic District Commission Door Replacement DATE: April 3, 2008 Mrs. Maiewski; At the regularly scheduled meeting of the Elm Street Historic District Commission held March 27, 2008, a unanimous vote was taken to approve the new door design specifications you submitted for 320 Elm Street. This wooden door, as proposed and attached herein, with the 2 lower molded recesses, is acceptable for the front elevation, right side. Thank you for your cooperation in this matter. If you have any questions, do not hesitate to contact me. z-F_z -2 A 5 (ID c6 Office of Planning and Development City of Northampton City Hall, 210 Main Street Northampton, MA 01060 (413) 587 -1288 telephone (413) 587 -1264 fax pkeller(northamptonma.gov 1 LJ /LVVV VJ r \P( l ?r Picture Door Email Date 2/29/2008 Email Time 08 :22 am I otes C, \Quote 2.wmf TM; MO/ Rt)" /S a 31 21 RP4 1 —SIDE 4118, 1 -3/8 HRP, 5/8' IG BF 1 EA 1 -3/4 5/8 MOD PANEL. STINKING LINE #2 if-A/6f, la/11 s I 7 7, 7 z 77 7 7 7; 7 ,7 w_Z,-, LJ /LVVV VJ r \P( l ?r Picture Door Email Date 2/29/2008 Email Time 08 :22 am I otes C, \Quote 2.wmf TM; MO/ Rt)" /S a 31 21 RP4 1 —SIDE 4118, 1 -3/8 HRP, 5/8' IG BF 1 EA 1 -3/4 5/8 MOD PANEL. STINKING LINE #2 if-A/6f, Peg Keller From: chris kennedy [e- modern @comcast.net] Sent: Tuesday, January 22, 2008 7:14 PM To: Kathy Borawski Cc: Chris Kennedy; Peg Keller; Anthony Patillo; Marissa Labozzetta Subject: Re: Elm Street door I did receive the door measurements and accordingly after receiving the sizes I made some calls to Springfield (United Wreckers) to try and assist you in finding you a lower cost option than a brand new door. I've also been in contact with Paul Britt who still travels in the architectural salvage circles and he has not come up with anything as yet either. Just to alleviate any confusion I did volunteer to see if a lower cost option to door replacement could be found but the onus of replacing your door was never solely on the commission's shoulders. The offer was nmeant as a way to save you money, not to take on the task of finding you a used door as the only solution. The commission's decision was for you, the property owner and the one who removed the original door, to replace the door with a wooden one in keeping with what was originally there. It was never incumbent upon the commission to replace your door. As the avenues that I have tried to find a used wooden alternative to a new wooden door have come up dry and a fair. amount of time has elapsed in the process, I think that finding a used door is no longer a viable option and that you should pursue a new wooden door that meets the approval of the commission. It is not the commission's desire to utilize the courts as a means of compliance, only as a last resort, so I'rn sure we can arrive at a resolve as long as you are willing to work with the commission in good faith. Please keep Peg apprised of your progress. Sincerely, Chris Kennedy On Jan 22, 2008, at 4:34 PM, Kathy Borawski wrote: Chris- Have you had any luck finding me a wooden door? I understand the historic commission is going to take legal action against me and I would like to avoid that. Last time we spoke, you asked for the door measurements and I sent them to you. Thanks. 1/23/2008 Kathy Borawski Broker /owner RE /MAX Hill Valley (413) 584 -5555 Fax: (413) 586 -0392 Celebrating 21 years in the real estate industry! Page 1' of 2 APPLICANT ADDRESS PHONE: t r r e trict ft 11 n bete USE THIS FORM ONLY AFTER A PUBLIC HEARING 031407 114 GEC' .51 :can OWNER. ADDRESS ��i RE: Land or Buildings at:ZO Elm Street, Northampton, ASSESSORS' MAP #51/ PARCEL )S The Historic District Commission has determined that (the Commission will check one of three boxes): If checked and signed, THE PROJECT IS APPROPRIATE under the ordinance and MGL C. 40C. THIS SERVES AS A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS, with the condition that all work be done in accordance with the description provided by the applicant in his/her application to the Historic District Commission and the following conditions (if any) If checked and signed, THERE IS A UNIQUE HARDSHIP under the ordinance and MGL. C. 40C. THIS SERVES AS A CERTIFICATE OF HARDSHIP, with the condition that all work be done in accordance with the description provided by the applicant in his/her application to the Historic District Commission and the following conditions (if any) PROJECT IS NOT APPROPRIATE NOR A HARDSHIP under the ordinance and M.G.L. C. 40C. THIS SERVES AS A DISAPPROVAL OF A CER11FICATE OF HARDSHIP. If, within 14 days, the applicant does not modify to their project as detailed below, THIS SHALL ALSO SERVE AS DISAPPROVAL OF A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS. If, within 14 days, the applicant addresses the reasons for denial and modifies their project as detailed below, and files these modifications with the Commission, the Commission shall, within a reasonable time period, issue a Certificate of Appropriateness. A Certificate of Appropriateness, with appropriate dimensional, set -back and other requirements and conditions cannot be issued without these modifications because the project, as described, does not meet the criteria. These requirements are only for the purpose of preventing developments incongruous to the historic aspects or characteristics of the surroundings and of the historic district September 25, 2007 7:00 p.m. 320 Elm Street 7:30 p.m. 300 Elm Street "pcvi -e_ct tQ -d7 PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT Cl1'Y OF NORTHAMPTON planning conservation zoning housing partnership redevelopment northampton GIS economic development community development historic comununity preservation central business architecture Peg Keller, Housing and Community Development Senior Planner PKeller@NorthamptonMA.gov 413 -587 -1288 ELM STREET HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE `The Elm Street Historic District Commission will hold a public hearing on September 25, 2007 at 7:00 p.m. in City Hall, Hearing Room 18, 210 Main Street, Northampton, MA. The hearing will be in regards to the application of Kathleen Maiewski for property at 320 Elm Street; Assessor's map 31A parcel 085. Applicant has replaced a wooden door with a metal on the front facade. Application of Robert P. Andrews to install a fire escape stairway from the second story to ground level on the west side of the building located at 300 Elm Street. At the second story level, a window will be converted to a door to access the stairway. Assessor's map 31A parcel 082. The applications are available for viewing in the Office of Planning and Development, City Hall, 210 Main Street, Northampton. Questions may be referred to Peg Keller, Housing and Community Development Planner at 587 -1288 or via email to pkeller @northaniptonma.gov City Hall 210 Main Street, Room 11 Northampton, MA 01060 www.NortharnptonMa.gov Fax 413 587 -1264 original printed on recycled paper September 25, 2007 7:00 p.m. 320 Elm Street 7:30 p.m. 300 Elm Street PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT CITY OF NORTHAMPTON planning conservation zoning housing partnership redevelopment northampton GIS economic development community development historic community preservation central business architecture Peg Keller, Housing and Community Development Senior Planner PKeller©NorthamptonMA.gov 413- 587 -1288 ELM STREET HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE The Elm Street Historic District Commission will hold a public hearing on September 25, 2007 at 7:00 p.m. in City Hall, Hearing Room 18, 210 Main Street, Northampton;MA. The hearing will be in regards to the application of Kathleen Maiewski for property at 320 Elm Street; Assessor's map 31A parcel 085. Applicant has replaced a wooden door with a metal one on the front facade. Application of Robert P. Andrews to install a fire escape stairway from the second story to ground level on the west side of the building located at 300 Elm Street. At the second story level, a window will be converted to a door to access the stairway. Assessor's map 31A parcel 082. The applications are available for viewing in the Office of Planning and Development, City Hall, 210 Main Street, Northampton. Questions may be referred to Peg Keller, Housing and Community Development Planner at 587 -1288 or via email to pkeller @northamptonma.gov City Hall 210 Main Street, Room 11 Northampton, MA 01060 www.NorthamptonMa.gov Fax 413 587 -1264 original printed on recycled paper 320 Elm Street ELM STREET HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING DECISION NOTICE The Elm Street Historic District Commission held a public hearing on Tuesday, September 25, 2007 at 7:00 p.m. in the Hearing Room of City Hall, 210 Main Street, Northampton, MA. Pursuant to Northampton Ordinance Chapter 27, notice is hereby given that a decision of the Commission has been filed in the City Clerk's Office on October 1, 2007. At the public hearing, the Elm Street Historic District Commission voted to deny the following: The application of Kathleen Maiewski for property at 320 Elm Street; Assessor's map 31A, parcel 085. Applicant has replaced a wooden door with a metal one on the front fagade. The applicant was instructed to remove the newly installed metal door and install a wooden door of similar design to the original wooden door that was removed. The applicant was given 30 days to comply. If anyone wishes to appeal this action, an appeal must be filed pursuant to Section 26 -8 of the City of Northampton's Ordinances. A written request must be filed with the Commission within twenty days after the filing of this notice with the City Clerk. The appeal will then be reviewed by a designee of the Pioneer Valley Regional Planning Commission. The decision and plans are available for review in the City of Northampton's Office of Planning and Development, City Hall, 210 Main Street, Northampton, MA. Peg Keller 587 -1288 pkeller ©northamptonma.gov Kathleen Borawski 218 Audubon Road Leeds, MA Dear Kathy; Respectfully, PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT CITY OF NORTHAMPTON City Hall 21 o Main Street, Room 1 t Northampton, MA o I o 6o -3 2 98 (413)587-1266 Fax: 587-1264 Warne Feiden Direcrrr� plainiC afi rtia4to [ila This letter is to follow up on the issue of the door replacement at your property on 320 Elm Street. The Ordinance states that "no building within the historic district shall be altered in any way that affects exterior architectural features, i.e. doors, ....without the appropriate certificate from the Commission. Ordinary maintenance, repair or replacement of any exterior architectural feature that involves a change in material requires review. It is my impression that the new door is something other than wood. If you choose to have this door remain, please submit an application to the Commission. If you choose to put the old door back on and resecure it, that is an option to consider in order to avoid coming before the Commission. Thank you for your cooperation in this matter. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me at 587 -1288. Margareller Housing and Community Development Planner Cc/ Anthony Patilio, Building Commissioner Elm Street Historic District Commission DEPT OF 3L L NG INSPECI K) IS f'!0%L"rii MPTONi, MA UNOG0 planning board conservation commission zoning board of appeals housing partnership redevelopment authority nortbampton GIs economic development community development historic district commission historical commission central business architecture originalprintedon recycled paper JUL 1 8 2007 April 19, 2007 org www.nortbamptonplanning.org